View Full Version : Consensus QB Rankings: #3
brady_branch
03-19-2008, 05:09 PM
Vote for the best one on the poll.
1. Johnny Unitas (http://www.football-almanac.com/players/Johnny_Unitas.shtml)
2. Joe Montana (http://www.football-almanac.com/players/Joe_Montana.shtml)
Brooklyn
03-20-2008, 08:07 AM
I voted for Graham (http://www.football-almanac.com/players/Otto_Graham.shtml). I see this vote as wide open.
It was a tough decision for me between the three receiving votes thus far (Elway (http://www.football-almanac.com/players/John_Elway.shtml), Favre (http://www.football-almanac.com/players/Brett_Favre.shtml) and Graham (http://www.football-almanac.com/players/Otto_Graham.shtml)). As a Bronco fan I watched Elway (http://www.football-almanac.com/players/John_Elway.shtml) a lot through the years and he just seemed so uncanny at times, not as prone to some of the bad lapses Favre (http://www.football-almanac.com/players/Brett_Favre.shtml) would have late (although Elway (http://www.football-almanac.com/players/John_Elway.shtml) had his rough spots) and with maybe better competition than Graham (http://www.football-almanac.com/players/Otto_Graham.shtml), especially if you count the AAFL.
I know who I'm voting for for position six, though.
Brooklyn
03-20-2008, 01:47 PM
It was a tough decision for me between the three receiving votes thus far (Elway, Favre and Graham). As a Bronco fan I watched Elway a lot through the years and he just seemed so uncanny at times, not as prone to some of the bad lapses Favre would have late (although Elway had his rough spots) and with maybe better competition than Graham, especially if you count the AAFL.
I know who I'm voting for for position six, though.
I tend to agree that this rounds out the top 5, but I struggle with the old-timers (Baugh, Jurgenson, Luckman, plus Granham, who I voted for), and those still playing (Manning, Brady). The late 70's / 80's and 90's for me are easier to sort out since I saw most of them for their full careers.
Galloping Ghost
03-20-2008, 02:30 PM
For the third time I voted for my man Otto (http://www.football-almanac.com/players/Otto_Graham.shtml). :D
brady_branch
03-25-2008, 07:01 PM
One day to go, and it looks like Otto Graham (http://www.football-almanac.com/players/Otto_Graham.shtml) will be the winner. If you haven't voted yet, but are reading this for whatever reason, please vote.