Trade Help

[ATLFalcons]

Somebody's offering me Peyton Manning and Greg Olsen for Chad Johnson and Steven Jackson. I know 85 is having a great season so far (thanks to last week shootout with the Browns) and Steven will eventually come around. Peyton is one of the most valuable QB's, but I already have Carson Palmer. My TE's are Tony Gonzalez and LJ Smith. So should I accept this trade?

[Fumble]

Somebody's offering me Peyton Manning and Greg Olsen for Chad Johnson and Steven Jackson. I know 85 is having a great season so far (thanks to last week shootout with the Browns) and Steven will eventually come around. Peyton is one of the most valuable QB's, but I already have Carson Palmer. My TE's are Tony Gonzalez and LJ Smith. So should I accept this trade?

no way in my opinion...

Manning is outstanding. but the who do you have to fill the void that would be left if you lost Chad and Steven?

To me Manning and Palmer... are close enough to not think twice about this trade...

DENIED!

[brady_branch]

Somebody's offering me Peyton Manning and Greg Olsen for Chad Johnson and Steven Jackson. I know 85 is having a great season so far (thanks to last week shootout with the Browns) and Steven will eventually come around. Peyton is one of the most valuable QB's, but I already have Carson Palmer. My TE's are Tony Gonzalez and LJ Smith. So should I accept this trade?

I don't play "typical" fantasy games any more, but to me, this looks like a no-way type of deal. Jackson is a stud, and more importantly, he's a RB. You don't trade a stud RB in football unless you get a stud RB back. And you've probably got the #2 QB (for fantasy purposes), so upgrading to #1 (Manning) shouldn't be necessary. And Greg Olsen is a rookie, and not just any rookie, but a rookie tight end who has Rex Grossman throwing him the ball. Point being, don't do it.

[ATLFalcons]

no way in my opinion...

Manning is outstanding. but the who do you have to fill the void that would be left if you lost Chad and Steven?

To me Manning and Palmer... are close enough to not think twice about this trade...

DENIED!

I don't play "typical" fantasy games any more, but to me, this looks like a no-way type of deal. Jackson is a stud, and more importantly, he's a RB. You don't trade a stud RB in football unless you get a stud RB back. And you've probably got the #2 QB (for fantasy purposes), so upgrading to #1 (Manning) shouldn't be necessary. And Greg Olsen is a rookie, and not just any rookie, but a rookie tight end who has Rex Grossman throwing him the ball. Point being, don't do it.


Thanks guys!! Trade Denied!